Blog

Hall Render Advisory Services News

Print PDF

The Leadership Challenge Health Care Executives Cannot Solve Alone

Posted on November 18, 2026 in Hall Render Advisory Services News

Written by: Hall Render Advisory Services

Health care executives rarely make major decisions in isolation from other priorities. An AI initiative can raise questions about governance, cybersecurity, privacy, workforce capacity and investment. Cybersecurity, EHR, workforce and financial decisions create similar tradeoffs, particularly for smaller and rural health care organizations.

Industry information can help leaders understand those issues. Applying that information within an individual organization requires something different: judgment informed by the organization’s resources, risks and circumstances.

Research suggests structured peer learning can add another source of experience to that process. A study involving managers from ten teaching hospitals found that participants associated peer learning with stronger decision-making, critical thinking and professional knowledge. The researchers also found that the benefits depended on structured opportunities for leaders to interact and exchange experiences.

Learning From Decisions Others Have Already Faced

The practical value of a peer group is not that another executive has the answer. It is that another executive may have already confronted part of the same problem.

A leader considering a technology investment may benefit from hearing what another organization encountered during implementation. Someone evaluating a partnership may learn which questions another executive wished they had asked earlier. An executive reassessing cybersecurity priorities can hear how peers have approached competing investments, limited resources or the aftermath of an incident.

These conversations give leaders something different from another source of industry information: the benefit of experience from decisions already made, including what worked, what did not and what others would approach differently the next time.

But that kind of exchange depends on trust. Executives are less likely to speak candidly about an unfinished strategy, organizational vulnerability or difficult decision if they have reason to be cautious about how that information could be used. That makes the composition and structure of a peer group more than an administrative detail. Who is in the room matters.

Creating the Conditions for Useful Peer Discussion

A 2024 study of 23 rural health care leaders identified structured interaction and interpersonal safety among the central components of collective leadership development. The researchers concluded that leadership development should not be viewed only as building the capabilities of individual leaders, but also as a relational process.

Those findings help explain why an executive peer group needs more than a collection of impressive résumés. A useful forum needs enough structure to move beyond networking, enough continuity for members to understand one another’s circumstances and an environment where executives can discuss difficult decisions candidly.

Building a Peer Forum for Health Care Leaders

Those principles informed the development of Leading Through Uncertainty: Executive Decision-Making in Health Care, a Leadership Cohort from Hall Render Advisory Services.

The cohort is designed for executives at small and midsize health care organizations, particularly those serving rural communities. It brings together five to seven leaders from non-competing organizations for six facilitated, 90-minute virtual sessions spanning four months.

Rather than presentations or webinars, sessions center on issues participants are actively navigating. Members share progress and roadblocks, work through live challenges and identify actions to carry forward. A professional facilitator and a Hall Render advisor participate in each session.

The non-competing structure is intentional. It is designed to reduce market concerns that could limit an executive’s willingness to discuss an unfinished strategy, organizational vulnerability or difficult decision.

Peer discussion cannot remove uncertainty from executive decision-making. But the evidence suggests that, when the right structure and environment are in place, it can give leaders something another report or webinar cannot: direct access to the experience of peers who are wrestling with many of the same decisions.

Executives interested in learning more about the program and participation criteria can visit go.hallrender.com/hrascohort to learn more.

If you have any questions or would like additional information about the cohort, please contact:

Hall Render and Hall Render Advisory Services blog posts and articles are intended for informational purposes only. For ethical reasons, Hall Render attorneys cannot—outside of an attorney-client relationship—answer specific questions that would be legal advice.

If you have any questions, please contact one of the following or your regular Hall Render Advisory Services consultant.

Daniel K. Cumberland's Photo

Daniel K. Cumberland

(410) 991-6322

Email
John M. Norling's Photo

John M. Norling

(214) 615-2010

Email
Mark D. Branstetter's Photo

Mark D. Branstetter

(615) 423-6651

Email